Warning
Info
Warning
Info
Simple English definitions for legal terms
bad-man theory
Read a random definition: strike
A quick definition of bad-man theory:
The bad-man theory is a belief that a bad person's understanding of the law is the best way to know what the law really is. This is because a bad person will carefully calculate what they can get away with and what the rules allow. The theory says that we should predict how the law will affect a person, rather than thinking about what is right or wrong. This theory was first talked about by Oliver Wendell Holmes in 1897. He said that we should look at the law as a bad person would, who only cares about avoiding punishment, not about being good. This theory is also called prediction theory.
A more thorough explanation:
Definition: Bad-Man Theory is a legal doctrine that suggests that the view of the law held by a bad person is the best way to understand what the law actually is. This is because a bad person will carefully calculate what the rules allow and operate up to the limits of those rules.
Oliver Wendell Holmes first introduced this theory in his essay "The Path of the Law" in 1897. According to Holmes, a society's legal system is defined by predicting how the law will affect a person, rather than considering the ethics or morals underlying the law. The prediction is best made by viewing the law as a "bad man" who is unconcerned with morals.
For example, imagine a person who wants to steal a car. They will carefully consider the laws related to car theft and plan their actions accordingly. They will not be concerned with whether stealing a car is morally right or wrong, but rather whether they can get away with it without incurring punishment by the law.
The Bad-Man Theory suggests that by understanding the perspective of a bad person, we can better understand how the law operates in practice. This theory is often associated with Legal Realism, which emphasizes the importance of understanding how the law is actually applied in the real world.